The Third Attempt: A Deep Dive into Chapter 12 of “The Mainspring of Human Progress” by Henry Grady Weaver
In Henry Grady Weaver’s influential book, The Mainspring of Human Progress, published in 1947, Chapter 12 titled “The Third Attempt” stands out as a pivotal exploration of the American Revolution’s role in human progress. Weaver’s narrative weaves through historical analysis to elucidate how individual freedom and responsibility have been instrumental in societal advancement, particularly during what he describes as the third significant attempt at achieving human liberty.
Historical Context and Weaver’s Thesis
Weaver frames “The Third Attempt” within the broader historical struggle for freedom, following the failed attempts by the ancient Israelites and the Islamic civilization during its golden age. The chapter centers on the American Revolution, portraying it not just as a fight for political independence from Britain but as a profound philosophical and economic revolution. Here, Weaver argues that the American experience demonstrated the power of individual human energy when unleashed through liberty, leading to unprecedented progress in technology, industry, and living standards.
Key Points of “The Third Attempt”
- The American Revolution as an Ideological Breakthrough: Weaver underscores that the Revolution was not merely about changing political rulers but about fundamentally altering the relationship between the individual and the state. The emphasis was on personal freedom, the sanctity of private property, and the minimal role of government, which Weaver sees as the cornerstone of progress.
- Individualism and Innovation: The chapter highlights how the American system of government, based on the principles of individual liberties, fostered an environment where inventiveness could flourish. Weaver cites examples like Eli Whitney’s cotton gin, which symbolized the inventive spirit that could be harnessed under freedom, leading to economic growth and societal improvement.
- The Role of the Unknown Individual: One of the most compelling arguments Weaver makes is the importance of the “unknown individual” in history. He posits that revolutions and significant societal changes are often sparked not by high-profile figures but by ordinary citizens exercising their newfound freedoms, thereby contributing to the collective progress.
- Unplanned Planning: Weaver introduces the concept of “unplanned planning,” suggesting that the spontaneous order of free individuals cooperating voluntarily results in more effective societal organization than any top-down planning could achieve. This idea aligns with the Austrian school of economics and thinkers like Friedrich Hayek, emphasizing the benefits of decentralized decision-making.
Critiques and Contemporary Relevance
While Weaver’s narrative is predominantly celebratory, not all scholars agree with his interpretation or the extent to which he credits liberty alone for America’s economic success. Critics might argue that factors like natural resources, geographical advantages, and even luck played significant roles. Moreover, the discussion on the relationship between freedom and progress has evolved, with modern debates often including considerations of social justice, environmental sustainability, and the balance between individual rights and collective welfare.
However, “The Third Attempt” remains relevant in contemporary discussions about the nature of freedom, the role of government, and the drivers of societal progress. Weaver’s insights into the power of individual initiative under a framework of liberty continue to resonate, particularly in arguments advocating for less government intervention in economic affairs.
Conclusion
Chapter 12 of The Mainspring of Human Progress by Henry Grady Weaver is a fascinating study of how the American Revolution served as a third significant attempt in the human quest for liberty. Weaver’s analysis not only honors the historical event but also uses it as a lens to view the broader implications of human freedom on progress. His advocacy for individual energy, minimal government, and the benefits of “unplanned planning” still provoke thought and debate, making his work a timeless piece in the discourse on human progress and liberty.
Sourcing References: